Rochester Judge John Plummer (c1719-1815)

By Muriel Bristol | November 22, 2026

John Plumer was born in Dover, NH, circa 1719, son of Richard and Elizabeth (Beard) Plumer.

Father Richard Plumer died in Dover, NH, June 26, 1745.

John Plumer married (1st), in 1748, Elizabeth Titcomb. She was born in Dover, NH, April 21, 1728, daughter of Daniel Titcomb.

(The known children of John and Elizabeth (Titcomb) Plumer were: Elizabeth Plumer (1750-1841), Joseph Plumer (1752–1821), Beard Plumer (1754–1816), and John Plumer (1761–1824)).

Daughter Elizabeth Plumer was born in Rochester, NH, in 1750. Mother Elizabeth (Beard) Plumer died in Dover, NH, August 30, 1750.

Son Joseph Plumer was born in Rochester, NH, in 1752. Son Beard Plummer was born in Rochester, NH, August 12, 1754.

Beard Plummer, son of John and Elizabeth Titcomb Plummer, was born in Rochester, N.H., to which place his father had moved from Newbury [MA] (Scales, 1914). 

Son John Plumer was born in Rochester, NH, in 1761.

Mrs. Elizabeth (Titcomb) Plummer died in Rochester, NH, January 26, 1770, aged forty-two years.

John Plumer married (2nd), circa 1770, Lydia ((Waterhouse) Colby) Dennett, he of Rochester, NH, and she of Portsmouth, NH. She was born in Portsmouth, NH, circa 1727-28, daughter of Timothy and Ruth (Moses) Waterhouse. She had married (1st) in Portsmouth, NH, August 23, 1747, Spencer Colby (1725-1751); (2nd) in Kittery, ME, February 24, 1751, Ephraim Dennett (1718-1770); and (3rd) John Plumer (1719-1815). She had a son, Jeremiah Dennett (1752-1818), who became a stepbrother to Beard Plumer and his siblings.

One of the ship masters employed by Sir Wm. Pepperell was Capt. [Spencer] Colby, who married Lydia Waterhouse. More than ninety years ago she became a widow, and afterwards was married to Ephraim Dennett, and resided at the above old mansion on Christian-shore [in Portsmouth, NH].
Years rolled on, and she again found herself a widow. Like a good housewife, in those days when no factories were in operation, she kept her flock of sheep, and attended to the various processes of converting their product into cloth; and her fame extended beyond the limits of the town. Near the house is a good spring which still flows on as of old. It was a time for wool washing. Laying aside the widow’s weeds, dressed in a leather apron, a man’s broad-brim hat, and other apparel to match she was washing her wool at the spring, when a stranger on horseback approached, and inquired for the residence of the widow Dennett. Nothing daunted, she pointed to the house, directed him to the front door, while she stepped round and entered the back way. He was not long in waiting before the lady of the house in comely apparel appeared.
The gentleman introduced himself as John Plummer of Rochester. He had heard of her good reputation, said perhaps it was too soon to come a courting, but would ask the privilege in proper time of proposing himself to her favorable consideration. In due time Judge Plummer came again, and they were married. They lived happily together many years, and their grave stones in Rochester record the ages of each at about ninety years.

Whether he ever inquired who it was he found washing wool at the spring, we have never been informed. If the events at the well where Rebecca was found were sufficient importance to be perpetuated, there is certainly enough of the primitive simplicity in the meeting at that spring to keep it in lasting remembrance by the descendants of that respectable family. To us, whenever we pass the premises – or are reminded of its history by seeing the elevated old mansion even across the millpond – there ever appears the vision of the Judge on his horse, and the industrious widow disguised under her broad-brim and leathern apron (Brewster, 1878).

Daughter Elizabeth Plumer married December 25, 1770, Aaron Wingate, she of Rochester, NH. He was born in Dover, NH, November 23, 1744, [twin] son of John and Sarah (Ricker) Wingate.

The Hon. Aaron Wingate settled in Farmington when it was almost a wilderness. He was a gentleman of distinguished ability, a sober, grave, judicious, man; for many years a member of the legislature; a counselor from 1797 to 1803; and for a succession of years, chief justice of the common pleas in Strafford county (Mitchell-Cony, 1908).

John Plummer served as Moderator of the Rochester, NH, Town Meeting of January 24, 1774, which had been called to consider a General Uneasiness prevailing in the towns of North America. He then served on the Rochester, NH, Committee of Correspondence.

PROVINCE OF NEW HAMPSHIRE. ROCHESTER RESOLVES. In Consequence of the General Uneasiness in the opulent Towns on the Continent of North America, and a Letter from the Committee of Correspondence, led us in these bye Parts to consider seriously the Cause of it; and we find Taxation without Representation (which as Lord Cambden well observes is inseparable) is the Cause of it. We consider our Constitution, that our Fore-Fathers at last to prevent hard Usage, left their Native Land, to enjoy that Liberty which they judged as freeborn Englishmen, they were entitled to. They then arrived on this then hostile Shore, which was a howling Wilderness, which was never purchased nor conquered at the Cost of Great-Britain, where they had to struggle with the Prospect of Famine, cold Season, besides combating an artful vindictive Enemy, and almost all other Difficulties that human Nature could surmount. When those Troubles were a little over, and the Sunshine of Prosperity began to arise, all hard Thoughts of the Mother Country’s Behaviour vanished, and they surrender’d Jurisdiction and Sovereignty to the Crown of Great Britain on Charters, with as strong Assurance as crowned Heads could give, that said Charters should be inviolably observed on both Sides; which Conditions were inserted in said Charters, by which we were to choose our own Representatives; to make and ordain Laws for the Regulation of said Colonies; raising Monies, and the like, not repugnant to the Laws of Great Britain. We have always cheerfully accepted the King’s Governor, and he has a negative Vote in our Assemblies, as the King has in Parliament; and Men or Money have been requested for upholding Government, it was readily granted, and raised where the Subjects could bear it best. Therefore, after all this, for the Parliament of Great-Britain to take such a Step over all Charters, and the most solemn Assurances, as to tax when and as they please, to raise a Revenue to support a Number of Hungry Placemen, of what Denomination soever, that distress peace able Subjects, and are a Pest to Society, that after all the Struggle in recovering the same, answers no other end but to alienate the Minds of the King’s most dutiful Subjects from him, and run the Nation in Debt on a Ballance. Oh! when will the Eyes of Administration be opened: we think our Behaviour has merited a more generous Treatment.
Therefore in Consideration of the above unhappy Situation of our American Brethren in general. At a legal Town Meeting of the Qualified Voters of the Town of Rochester, assembled at the Meeting House in said Town, on Monday the 24th of this Instant January, A.D. 1774, to consider on the alarming Circumstances of this once free country.
1. John Plummer, Esq., chosen Moderator of said Meeting.
2. Voted unanimously that it is our deliberate Opinion that we are freeborn, and loyal Subjects of the Crown of Great-Britain, and as such depend on Protection, and not Slavery.
3. That the present King GEORGE the Third is our lawful Sovereign; and the Heirs of his Body, in the Protestant Line are so to remain; and as such promise to pay him all lawful obedience, agreeable to our happy Constitution, and that we will so render Tribute to him as his Due.
4. That as such freeborn Subjects, we will to our utmost be on our Watch that no artful designing Men of any Rank soever, may deprive us of our Privileges by creeping in at unawares, to undermine us of this Jewel Liberty, by setting up their Placemen to pray and sport with the same.
5. Voted that the Hon. John Plummer, John McDuffee, Ebenezer Tebbits, Esqrs., and Daniel Wingate, be a Committee to correspond with their Brethren Committees, in the neighboring Towns or any Three of them.
6. Voted that a Copy of this be sent to the Committee of Correspondence at Portsmouth, assuring them that our Hearts are Knit with theirs in the noble Cause of Freedom. And the meeting Dissolved. JOHN PLUMER, Moderator.
A true Copy, from the Original Vote of the Meeting. Attest, JOSIAH MAIN, Town Clerk (McDuffee, Franklin, 1892).

Son Joseph Plumer married in Rochester, NH, November 30, 1778, Hannah Bickford, both of Rochester, NH. She was born in 1756.

Son Beard Plummer married (1st) in Rochester, NH, September 7, 1780, Susanna Ham. She was born in Rochester, NH, October 9, 1762, daughter of Captain Jonathan and Elizabeth (Ham) Ham.

John Plummer headed a Rochester, NH, household at the time of the First (1790) Federal Census. His household included four males aged 16-plus years [himself], four females [Elizabeth (Titcomb) Plummer], and one male aged under-16 years. Their household appeared in the enumeration between those of Isaac Brown and Benja Odiorne. (See Northeast Parish in the First (1790) Federal Census).

Aaron Wingate headed a Rochester, NH, household at the time of the First (1790) Federal Census. His household included two males aged 16-plus years [himself], two males aged under-16 years, and three females [Elizabeth (Plummer) Wingate]. Their household appeared in the enumeration between those of Mordecai Varney and James Downs. (See Northeast Parish in the First (1790) Federal Census).

Joseph Plummer headed a Rochester, NH, household at the time of the First (1790) Federal Census. His household included two males aged 16-plus years [himself] one male aged under-16 years, and four females [Hannah (Bickford) Plummer]. Their household appeared in the enumeration between those of Beard Plummer and James Hayes. (See Northeast Parish in the First (1790) Federal Census).

Beard Plumer headed a Northeast Parish, Rochester, NH, household at the time of the First (1790) Federal Census. His household included two males aged 16-plus years [himself], four females [Susanna (Ham) Plumer], and four males aged under-16 years. His household appeared in the enumeration between those of Timothy Gerrish and Joseph Plummer. (See also Northeast Parish in the First (1790) Federal Census).

John Plumer headed a Rochester, NH, household at the time of the Second (1800) Federal Census. His household included one male aged 45-plus years [himself], one female aged 45-plus years [Elizabeth (Titcomb) Plumer], one male aged 26-44 years, one female aged 26-44 years, one male aged 16-25 years, one female aged 16-25 years, two males aged 10-15 years, and one female aged 10-15 years. (See also Northeast Parish in the Second (1800) Federal Census).

Aaron Wingate headed a Farmington, NH, household at the time of the Second (1800) Federal Census. His household included one male aged 45-plus years [himself], one female aged 45-plus years [Elizabeth (Plummer) Wingate], one male aged 26-44 years, one male aged 16-25 years, two females aged 16-25 years, and two females aged under-10 years.

Joseph Plumer headed a Northeast Parish, Rochester, NH household at the time of the Second (1800) Federal Census. His household included one male aged 45-plus years [himself], one female aged 45-plus years [Hannah (Bickford) Plummer], one male aged 16-25 years, two males aged 16-25 years, two males aged 10-15 years, and one female aged 10-15 years. (See also Northeast Parish in the Second (1800) Federal Census).

Beard Plumer headed a Northeast Parish, Rochester, NH household at the time of the Second (1800) Federal Census. His household included one male aged 45-plus years [himself], one female aged 26-44 years [Susanna (Ham) Plummer], two males aged 16-25 years, two females aged 16-25 years, one male aged 10-15 years, one female aged 10-15 years, two males aged under-10 years, and one female aged under-10 years. (See also Northeast Parish in the Second (1800) Federal Census).

Son-in-law Honl Aaron Wingate was a Court of Common Pleas Chief Justice, December 28, 1802.

Daughter-in-law Susanna (Ham) Plummer died in Milton, February 20, 1803.

Son-in-law Aaron Wingate received a five-year appointment as a Rochester, NH, justice-of-the-peace and justice-of-the-quorum, December 21, 1803.

Beard Plummer married (2nd) in Dunbarton, NH, circa March 1804, Achsah Page, he of Milton and she of Dunbarton, NH. She was born in Dunbarton, NH, September 25, 1759, daughter of Jeremiah and Sarah (Merrill) Page.

MARRIED. At Dunbarton, Beard Plumer, Esq., of Milton, to Miss Achsah Page, daughter of the Hon. Jeremiah Page, of Dunbarton (NH Courier (Concord, NH), April 4, 1804).

Son John Plummer, Junior, received a five-year appointment as a Rochester, NH, justice-of-the-peace and justice-of-the-quorum, December 5, 1804.

Son John Plummer, Jr, received a five-year reappointment as a Rochester, NH, justice-of-the-peace and justice-of-the-quorum, September 19, 1809.

John Plummer, Esqr, headed a Rochester, NH, Household at the time of the Third (1810) Federal Census. His household included two males aged 45-plus years [himself], one female aged 45-plus years [Elizabeth (Titcomb) Plummer], one male aged 16-25 years, one female aged 16-25 years, one male aged 10-15 years, one female aged 10-15 years.

Aaron Wingate headed a Farmington, NH, household at the time of the Third (1810) Federal Census. His household included one male aged 45-plus years [himself], one female aged 45-plus years [Elizabeth (Plummer) Wingate], two males aged 26-44 years, one female aged 26-44 years, one male aged 16-25 years, two females aged 16-25 years, and one female aged 10-15 years. His household appeared in the enumeration between those of Jacob Varney and Jno Downs.

Joseph Plumer headed a Milton household at the time of the Third (1810) Federal Census. His household included one male aged 45-plus years [himself], one female aged 45-plus years [Hannah (Bickford) Plummer], one male aged 26-44 years, two females aged 26-44 years, one male aged 16-25 years, one female aged 16-25 years, three males aged 10-15 years, one female aged 10-15 years, and one male aged under-10 years. His household appeared in the enumeration between those of Wd Betsy Hayes and Beard Plumer. (See Milton in the Third (1810) Federal Census).

Beard Plumer headed a Milton household at the time of the Third (1810) Federal Census. His household included one male aged 45-plus years [himself], one female aged 45-plus years [Achsah (Page) Plumer], one male aged 26-44 years, two males aged 16-25 years, two females aged 16-25 years, one male aged 10-15 years, and one female aged 10-15 years. His household appeared in the enumeration between those of Joseph Plummer and Peter Gerrish. (See Milton in the Third (1810) Federal Census).

Son-in-law Aaron Wingate received a five-year reappointment as a Farmington, NH, justice-of-the-peace and quorum, September 22, 1810.

Daughter-in-law Hannah (Bickford) Plummer died in Rochester, NH, February 11, 1811.

Mrs. Lydia (((Waterhouse) Colby) Dennett) Plumer died in Rochester, NH, August 4, 1812, aged eighty-four years.

Sons Beard Plumer and Joseph Plumer signed the Milton Congregational Society petition of June 1814. (See Milton Congregational Society Petition – 1814).

John Plumer died in Rochester, NH, November 19, 1815, aged ninety-six years.

LONGEVITY. In Rochester, N.H., Hon. John Plummer, Esq., aged 96 (The Recorder (Greenfield, MA), January 2, 1816).

Son John Plumer of Rochester, NH, made his last will, June 20, 1817. He devised $100 to John Plumer Dennett of Portsmouth, NH; $100 to John P. Plumer March, son of the late Jonas C. March, Esq., of Rochester, NH; and all the rest and remainder to his son, John Plumer, 3d, who he also named as executor. John McDuffee, Benjamin Hayes, and Abigail McDuffee witnessed his signature (Strafford County Probate, 32:113). John Plumer Dennett (1785-1867), son of stepbrother Jeremiah Dennett, was a step-grandson and namesake of Judge John Plumer (1719-1815). John Plumer March. (1811-1897), son of Jonas C. and Lydia (Wingate) March, was a grandson of Elizabeth (Plumer) Wingate and great grandson of John Plumer.

Son Beard Plummer died in Milton, October 7, 1816, aged sixty-two years.

OBITUARY. In Milton, New Hampshire, Hon. Beard Plumer, aged 62 (Christian Disciple (Boston, MA), November 1816).

His last will was proved in a Strafford County Probate court held at Dover, NH, October 23, 1816 (Strafford County Probate, 17:525). Achsah Plumer, widow of Beard Plumer, Esq., late of Milton, waived her bequest as set out in his will, and requested instead to have her dower assigned to her as if he had died intestate (Strafford County Probate, 17:529).

NEW-HAMPSHIRE. … In the Senate of this State there are of the Legislature, two vacancies, one occasioned by the acceptance of a judiciary appointment by the Hon. B. Badger, and the other by the decease of the Hon. Beard Plumer. These vacancies are likely to occasion some embarrassment in the government of that state. They are required by the constitution to be filled by election by the other House, from the two remaining highest candidates in their several districts. In each of the present cases it is said that the highest remaining candidates are federalists, so that the other House, though democratic, will be under the necessity of supplying the vacancies with federalists, an event which would destroy the predominance of the democratic party in the Senate, and give the federalists a check upon the proceedings. Another report is, that there are no two highest candidates in either distinct, all the votes in each being given to one man, except that two other persons in each district had each one vote (Burlington Gazette (Burlington, VT), December 5, 1816).

Son Joseph Plumer died April 27, 1821, aged sixty-nine years. (For details of his last will see Milton Taverner Levi Jones (1771-1847)).

Daughter-in-law Achsah (Page) Plumer married (2nd) in Dunbarton, NH, April 18, 1822, Enoch Coffin, she of Dunbarton, NH, and he of Concord, NH. Rev. Walter Harris, V.D.M.

MARRIAGES. Mrs. Achsah Plummer, widow of Hon. Beard Plummer, married Capt. Enoch Coffin of Concord, N.H., in Dunbarton, N.H. (Columbian Centinel (Boston, MA), May 22, 1822). 

Son-in-law Aaron Wingate died in Farmington, NH, in May 1822, aged seventy-eight years.

DIED. In Farmington, N.H., Hon. Aaron Wingate, Judge in the Court of Common Pleas for the County of Strafford, N.H., aged 78 years (Columbian Centinel (Boston, MA), May 9, 1822).

Hon. Aaron Wingate, for many years a member of the legislature, a counsellor from 1797 to 1803, and for sometime chief-justice of the common pleas in Strafford, died here in 1822, aged 78 years (New England Gazetteer, 1839).

Judge Wingate left a worthy family. Madam Wingate survived her husband a number of years (Wyatt, 1854).

Son John Plumer died in Rochester, NH, May 13, 1824, aged sixty-two years.

DIED. In Rochester, N.H., John Plumer, aged 63 years (Columbian Centinel (Boston, MA), May 22, 1824).

Enoch Coffin headed a Concord, NH, household at the time of the Fifth (1830) Federal Census. His household included one male aged 70-79 years [himself], one female aged 70-79 years [Achsah ((Page) Plummer) Coffin], one male aged 30-39 years, one female aged 30-39 years, three males aged 20-29 years, one female aged 20-29 years, and one female aged 15-19 years.

Achsah [((Page) Plummer)] Coffin headed a Dunbarton, NH, household at the time of the Sixth (1840) Federal Census. Her household included one female aged 80-89 years [herself], one male aged 30-39 years, and one female aged 15-19 years. One member of her household was engaged in Agriculture.

Daughter Elizabeth (Plumer) Wingate died in 1841.

Daughter-in-law Achsah ((Page) Plummer) Coffin died in Dunbarton, NH, September 30, 1841.


References:

Find a Grave. (2021, November 8). Beard Plumer. Retrieved from www.findagrave.com/memorial/233852302/beard-plumer

Find a Grave. (2010, February 20). Hon. John Plumer. Retrieved from www.findagrave.com/memorial/48404230/john-plumer

Find a Grave. (2010, February 20). John Plumer. Retrieved from www.findagrave.com/memorial/48404231/john-plumer

Find a Grave. (2021, November 4). Joseph Plumer. Retrieved from www.findagrave.com/memorial/233700428/joseph-plumer

McDuffee, Franklin. (1892). History of the Town of Rochester, New Hampshire. Retrieved from www.google.com/books/edition/History_of_the_Town_of_Rochester_New_Ham/RY0-AAAAYAAJ?&pg=PA53

Unknown's avatar

Author: Muriel Bristol

"Lady drinking tea"

Leave a Reply